Tmt, provides new insights into the upper echelons research stream. The organization as a reflection of its top managers. Opening up the black box of upper echelons theory the ability to continuously develop innovative processes, products and services has long been recognized to be a vital factor in remaining competitive in the market e. Drawing on upper echelons theory and behavioral decision theory, we developed and tested hypotheses using original survey data from 2,790 ceos of diverse manufacturing firms in china. It is hoped that the result of this paper can fill the gap of the literature on the relationship between ceo personal characteristics and financial leverage as explained by upper echelon theory. Second, while upper echelons theory has found that senior management effects are moderated by external forces hambrick, 2007, we show that a differentiated structural element within an organization may also modify the discretion of senior. View upper echelons theory research papers on academia. Manuscript upper echelons theory in management accounting.
According to the upper echelons theory, as set forth by hambrick and mason 1984, a central requirement for understanding organizational behavior is to identify those factors that direct or orient executive attention. Upper echelons theory focuses on the characteristics of the top management team and especially the top executives who have great power to influence decision making of organizations. Strategic decisions made by managers in organizations represent the significant impact community has on top. The theory simply attributes the performance outcomes of firms to the characteristics of their top management teams and associates heterogeneity of the strategic behavior of firms with the cognitive and behavioral diversity of their managerial teams. According the the authors their results provide sufficient evidence that. Upper echelons, corporate structure, and philanthropy upper echelons research focuses on the ways in which the biases, egos, aptitudes, experiences, and other individual characteristics of senior leaders influence the range of strategic options they consider and the decisionmaking processes by which they select from among those. Teori ini juga menunjukkan bahwa usia, pengalaman, pendidikan, latar belakang sosial, kondisi ekonomi, dan karakteristik kelompok dimana dia berada, merupakan. Table 1 summarizes the key premise of each theory and illustrates some potential implications of the theory for sustainability. A largesample empirical study of the antecedents of female participation in top management the low rates of female participation in top management represent a puzzle, especially since. Upper echelons of nokia nokia is one of the leading companies in the sector of advanced technologies and mobile network with an advantage of 100 years of experience and expertise in telecommunications from 2g to 3g to 4g and now the emerging 5g. We conclude with a discussion of the studys results, contributions to theory and practice, limitations, and directions for future research. The definition of the upper echelon theory mainly states that, decisionmaking is based on the interpretations of the executives. Measuring executive personality using machinelearning.
A theory of expert leadership iza institute of labor. A largesample empirical study of the antecedents of female participation in top management cristian l. The current situation if compared to the previous phase, will give us a fair view of how the organizations performance can be forecasted keeping in mind the upper echelons theory. Organizations wishing to attract, retain, and benefit from diverse talent are often advised to. This study integrates and extends the literature on upper echelons theory uet and institutional theory by investigating general manager gm strategic decision making in the north american professional sport context. Samih, ramzi and timo are the top executives and also hold an interesting mix of experience which includes sizeable time spent within telecom and cellular companies. Pdf download for metacritiques of upper echelons theory.
Upper echelons theory predicts two moderating factors that would cause crosssectional variations in managerspecific effects. Examining upper echelons managers characteristics on financial. Upper echelons research has largely focused on the antecedents and. Ceos values, management style and firm performance. The route to good theory leads not through gaps in the literature but through an engagement with problems in the world that you find personally interesting. Upper echelons theory uet is one of the mostresearched theories in organization and management literature.
The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results. Upper echelon theory highlights the importance of top management teams in large and. At the invitation of the editor, i recap the article in which the theory was originally presented, discuss subsequent refinements of the theory, and lay out several promising avenues for. To generate these rules or principles, bernstein distinguishes between the underlying invisible structures through which a pedagogic subject is realised, and what he calls. Should the article be accepted for publication, authors will have to convert their files to word for copy editing. Authors who are unable to submit anything but pdf files must contact the asq editorial office. Pdf external environment and upper echelons theory. Esteve and others published external environment and upper echelons theory. It builds on upper echelon theory to posit that community level characteristics are instrumental in framing the cognitions of ceos and top executives. How managerial characteristics affect corporate strategic change. According to contingency theory, organizations strategy is a function of the. The relationship between upper echelon diversity, the adoption of diversity practices, and organizational performance. Data from proprietary assessments that rate each candidate on 30 dimensions.
The need for a change from causal description to upper echelons theory states that organizational. It states that organizational outcomes are partially predicted by managerial background characteristics of the top level management team. Due to the reason that managerial values and perceptions are difficult to measure, the upper echelons theory draws prior. In viewing strategy, and in interpreting strategic possibilities, members of the organizations upper echelons inevitably do so through the lens of their through their.
Firm innovation is an important outcome, and there is evidence that it can be affected by. Resource deployment strategies following initial public offering. The upper echelons theory is a management theory published by donald c. In the modified casual model of the upper echelons theory, carpenter et al. Developed three decades ago, upper echelons theory uet stated that organizational. Higgins b,1 a columbia business school, 719 uris hall, new york, ny 10027 united states b harvard graduate school of education, 425 gutman, cambridge, ma 028 united states abstract alliances with established organizations provide.
Hambrick and masons upper echelons theory uet stands as one of. Using the characteristics of small business managers to. This study relates proposition 21 of hambrick and masons 1984 upper echelons theory uet to paul and timothys leadership of the ephesian church. Examining upper echelons managers characteristics on. Fokus terhadap karakteristi k manajemen puncak akan. The model depicts the main characteristics which may substantially influence smes managers decision on it adoption behaviour. This research examines individual contextual variables and the institutional environment in each league as they impact the. The proposal is expected to include 1 conceptual and literature background, 2 theory development and hypotheses, and 3 methodology. In recent years, scholars have started to draw on upper echelons theory to analyze the relationship between the characteristics of top managers and management accounting and control systems.
This paper attempts to synthesize these previously fragmented litera tures around a more general upper echelons perspective. Then, we draw on upper echelons theory to develop two hypotheses and describe our research context and the methodology used to test the hypothesized relationships. It has always been and intends to remain at the cutting edge of mobile technology. The top management team, formulation of corporate strategy. Upper echelons theory has its roots in behavioural theory of the firm nielsen, 2010, which at its core centres on impacts of managers cognitions, values and perceptions on the strategic choices. Using survey data from 228 chief executives from catalonia, we test upper echelons theory, and control for top managers. How has upper echelons theory uet hambrick and mason, 1984 been evolving over time. The theory simply attributes the performance outcomes of firms to the characteristics of their top management teams and associates heterogeneity of the strategic behavior of firms with the cognitive and behavioral diversity of their managerial. Upper echelons theory, favoured by macrotheorists and strategists waldman and javidan, 2001, rejects the deterministic view taken by proponents of external control and focuses on the personal characteristics of toplevel managers. At the invitation of the editor, i recap the amr article. Evidence from social enterprise in europe marieke huysentruyt site, stockholm school of economics and social business chair, hec paris ute stephan economics and strategy group, aston business school suncica vujic department of economics, university of antwerp march 2015 abstract.
The paper shows that existing research consistently. To address this question, the management field has accumulated a substantial amount of research over the past three decades built on upper echelons theory uet, which posits that ceo characteristics manifest in firm strategic actions and, in this way, future firm performance. In particular, in four cumulative studiesthe dissertation explores. Hambrick the pennsylvania state university the central premise of upper echelons theory is that executives experiences, values, and personalities greatly influence their interpretations of the situations they face and, in turn, affect their choices. Dec 18, 20 in recent years, scholars have started to draw on upper echelons theory to analyze the relationship between the characteristics of top managers and management accounting and control systems. Since many of the studies failed to show empirically how or why top management demographics related to organizational outcomes, implications for theory and. Antecedents and consequences of top management team. Empirical research on upper echelon theory is fairly new empirical findings suggest that management influences financial reporting outcomes. The idea that leadership is associated with superior intelligence originates in the. Teori upper echelons pertama kali diperkenalkan oleh hambrick dan mason 1984. The suggestion that leader characteristics should closely align with.
The relationship between cahrs wp0704 page 3 of 14. Do ceos personal values affect employees innovative work behavior. This study employs different methods pooled ols regression and fixed effects panel regression for the analysis. Pdf download for the role of external environment in upper. Financial restatement, upper echelon theory, managers characteristics, listed firms, malaysia. The united states general accounting office gao 2002. However,with increased emphasis on pluralistic theorization and the big tent view, our domain is opening up to boundaryspanning research. In fact, after more than 30 years since its original conceptualization, the authors believe that the ue field is mature enough. Mason columbia university theorists in various fields have discussed characteristics of top manag ers. The role of external environment in upper echelons theory. Toward a theoretical toolbox for sustainability research. Sme managers perceptions of competitive pressure and the.
Do ceos personal values affect employees innovative work. For instance, the microfoundations research in upper echelons has forged boundaryspanning re. Upper echelons theory in management accounting and control. Connecting resource based, upper echelons, and agency perspectives welcome to the ideals repository javascript is disabled for your browser. The understanding that the senior executives of an organization the ceo and hisher selected team are responsible for strategic formation and enactment. The organization as a reflection of its top managers1 donald c. Mason 1984, upper echelons theory is the idea that top executives view their situations through their own highly personalized lenses. However, hambrick 2007 stated in an update on his initial article on upper echelons theory, that the psychological and social processes by which executive profiles are converted into strategic choices still remain largely a mistery the proverbial black box p. Second, in support of resourcebased theory, the joint experience of managers in the top management team prepares them for making intense. Toward a theoretical toolbox for sustainability research in. Firm innovation is an important outcome, and there is evidence that it can be affected by the characteristics of a firms top executives. Resource deployment strategies following initial public. Higgins b,1 a columbia business school, 719 uris hall, new york, ny 10027 united states. In this paper, we argue that community plays an important role in shaping the values and characteristics of top management teams.
1570 1520 362 227 1556 886 723 704 1375 1661 175 1269 365 1355 214 434 1449 429 302 1284 1626 1241 547 1287 381 1009 21 774 259 336 540 1063 863